Most business owners I meet fall into one of two camps with their website numbers. Either they never look, because the analytics dashboard is overwhelming and nothing in it seems actionable. Or they look at one number, usually total visitors, and feel good or bad about it without knowing what to do next.
Both are reasonable reactions to a tool built for marketing departments. But there are five numbers that actually tell you whether your website is doing its job, and you can check all of them in about ten minutes a month. Here they are.
1. Visitors From Search
What it is: How many people found your site through Google (or Bing) in a given month, not counting people who typed your name.
Where it's hiding: Google Search Console, "Performance" tab. It shows clicks and the actual search terms people used. Google Analytics 4 shows something similar under Acquisition, but Search Console is more honest and more useful for this.
What bad looks like: A flat or falling line over three months, or a search term list that's only your business name. If nobody finds you by searching for what you do, the site isn't bringing new customers, only ones who already knew you.
What to do: Read the search terms. If people are finding you for things you don't want, or not finding you for things you do, that's the roadmap. The local SEO checklist is where I'd start.
2. Your Top Landing Pages
What it is: The pages people arrive on first. Not the pages they visit most, the ones that are their first impression.
Where it's hiding: GA4, Reports → Engagement → Landing page. Or Search Console, "Pages" tab, which shows which pages get clicks from search.
What bad looks like: Your homepage is the only page anyone lands on. That means your service pages aren't ranking for anything on their own, which is where most new customers should be arriving.
What to do: Check that your top landing pages have a clear next step (a phone number, a form, a button) near the top. Someone who lands on your "water heater repair" page should be able to call you without visiting another page.
3. Contact Actions
What it is: How many people tapped your phone number, submitted a form, or clicked to email you. This is the number that connects the website to your bank account.
Where it's hiding: GA4 can track these as "events" or "key events," but it usually has to be set up. If yours isn't, that's the single most valuable hour anyone could spend on your analytics. In the meantime, count form submissions in your inbox and ask new callers how they found you.
What bad looks like: Lots of visitors, very few contacts. A site with 500 visitors and 3 contacts a month has a conversion problem, not a traffic problem. More visitors won't fix it.
What to do: Look at the pages people visit before leaving without contacting you. Usually the fix is obvious once you see it: no phone number on the page, a form with too many fields, or a page that doesn't say what you actually do. I covered the form side in your contact form is losing you leads.
4. Mobile Share
What it is: The percentage of your visitors on a phone.
Where it's hiding: GA4, Reports → Tech → Overview, or add "Device category" to almost any report.
What bad looks like: The number itself is rarely the problem. For most local businesses it's 60–80%. What's bad is when the mobile visitors contact you at a much lower rate than desktop visitors. That means the phone version of your site is broken in some way the desktop version isn't.
What to do: Use your own site on your phone, on cellular, and try to contact yourself. Whatever annoys you is annoying everyone.
5. Page Speed
What it is: How quickly your site loads and becomes usable, especially on a phone.
Where it's hiding: Google's PageSpeed Insights (search for it, paste in your URL). Look at the mobile score and the "Core Web Vitals" assessment at the top.
What bad looks like: A "Failed" Core Web Vitals assessment, or a mobile score in the red. In practice: if it takes more than three seconds to see something useful on a phone, you're losing people before they read a word.
What to do: Almost always, it's images that are too large, too many plugins or scripts, or cheap hosting. The details are in why your website feels slow.
The Ten-Minute Monthly Routine
Here's the whole thing on one calendar reminder:
| Minute | Check | Ask |
|---|---|---|
| 0–3 | Search Console: clicks and top queries | Are people finding me for what I do? |
| 3–5 | Search Console: top pages | Are my service pages showing up, or just the homepage? |
| 5–7 | Contacts: form submissions + tracked calls | How many leads did the site produce? |
| 7–8 | GA4: device category | Are mobile visitors contacting me as often as desktop? |
| 8–10 | PageSpeed Insights: mobile | Did anything get slower? |
Write the five numbers in a spreadsheet, one row per month. After three months you'll see trends. After a year you'll know more about your website than most agencies would tell you.
If you want to turn those numbers into a dollar figure, website ROI walks through it. A business in Sacramento I work with does exactly this routine on the first of every month and can tell you, to the dollar, what their site is worth to them.
The Bottom Line
You don't need to understand Google Analytics. You need five numbers: search visitors, landing pages, contact actions, mobile share, and speed. Together they tell you whether people are finding you, whether the right pages are working, and whether the site is turning visitors into calls.
Check them monthly. Ignore almost everything else.
Not sure where your numbers stand, or whether tracking is even set up right? Get a free audit and I'll pull the five that matter and tell you what they say.
Want help applying this to your business?
Get a free website audit and a personalized action plan. No pressure, no sales pitch.
Get a Free Audit